Get Informed View Complete Daily Q&A Archive
What do you know about the supplement Hoodia as an appetite suppressant? I tried it. It seems to really diminish the feeling of hunger but of course I'm interested in your perspective.

Hoodia has become a popular weight loss product used to suppress appetite.

Hoodia is a succulent plant that grows in the South African desert and used by a tribe to curb appetite, quench thirst, increase endurance when on long hunting expeditions and when food is scarce. The plant's active ingredient has been identified as P57, and has been patented by PhytoPharm*. In an unpublished study by PhytoPharm, a small group of men took P57 (not the Hoodia plant) and cut back on calories and lost weight. At this time, no supplements contain the patented P57; therefore you are likely to get a product called Hoodia that contains little or none of the purported active ingredient. The Hoodia plant is now grown in many different regions but no one knows if the plants outside the Kalahari Desert have the same effect on the body. More significantly no one knows if Hoodia is safe, especially if used continuously. The tribesmen themselves rarely used it and not for weight loss. One of the original researchers from Pfizer cautioned "that P57 may have unwanted effects on the liver."

Due to the lack of published human research and safety data as well as the aforementioned uncertainty of the currently sold products' actual contents, we recommend you stay clear of any supplement claiming to contain Hoodia Gordonii.

 

*Hoodia's active ingredient is a steroidal glycoside, labeled P57AS3. The active component seems to exert its effects on the hypothalamus by increasing ATP activity. To date there has been only one published study on Hoodia gordonii, or more specifically P57. It involved injecting rats with P57 directly into the hypothalamus and then recording the effect on appetite. Rats injected with P57 decreased their food intake 50-60% over a 24-hour period.[i] The effect on appetite increased with a higher dose. Whether or not the decrease in appetite would result in weight loss is not known. After the initial 24-hour period (after injection), the rats were euthanized to study the effects of P57 on brain tissue.



[i] MacLean DB, Luo LG. Increased ATP content/production in the hypothalamus may be a signal for energy-sensing of satiety: studies of the anorectic mechanism of a plant steroidal glycoside.
Brain Res. 2004 Sep 10;1020(1-2):1-11.


User Comments

1. 60 Minutes aired an investigation into Hoodia a few years ago, and you can still find the transcript of the segment online. I believe Pfizer dropped out of the partnership with Phytopharm because they were unable to replicate the active ingredient in synthetic form. As a result, they couldn't produce a pill that contained the active ingredient, which reveals that no one else's pills contain the active ingredient either. Now, Phytopharm is trying to mass-produce the crop in South Africa, so they can use it in liquid form for drinks and food products.

One particular Hoodia product is the only diet pill Oprah has ever endorsed, but she also had as a guest the plastic surgeon who has been sued 5 times for malpractice and is unaccredited. Just goes to show...
Add Your Comments
POST A NEW COMMENT BELOW
You must be logged in to make a post.
 
Home  |  About Us  |  Contact Us |  User Agreement  |  Privacy Policy | 

This information and other information on this site is intended for general reference purposes only and is not intended to address specific medical or health conditions. This information is not a substitute for professional medical advice or a medical exam. Prior to taking nutritional supplements or participating in any diet or exercise program or activity, you should seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health professional. No health information on this site should be used to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any medical condition.
bodybugg is a registered trademark of 24 Hour Fitness USA, Inc., registered in the United States Patent and Trademark Office.

Copyright © 2005 - 2009 by Apex Fitness Inc. All rights reserved.